 |
 |
| Titre : |
Managers as sensemakers. A polyphonic approach of organizational identities |
|
| Numéro : |
46 |
|
| Année : |
2012 |
|
| Volume : |
XVIII |
|
| Auteur(s) : |
François PICHAULT, Giseline RONDEAUX |
|
| Résumé : |
In a situation of crisis or deep organizational disruption, organizational identity often appears as a critical dimension (Albert et Whetten, 1985 ; Alvesson et Empson, 2008 ; Dutton et al, 1994). It cannot be considered as monolithic: each stage of the evolution of the organization is marked by several interactions (different identity logics predominate each other at times). Even if within an organizational identity, a particular identity logic seems to prevail, other identity logics are nevertheless present, or appear in informal mode. Organizational identity is thus conceived as hybrid : on the one hand, the dominant identity logic, on the other hand, alternative identity logics consisting in different perceptions of the organization’s central, enduring and distinctive features, its values and running principles.
Because of their formal authority and their access to resources, managers play an important role in organizational identification processes. They can first create meaning around a deliberate change (sensegiving). Such an approach emphasizes the role of organizational leaders (carriers of the dominant identity logic) in a cognitive process where they aim at providing to the members of the organization a coherent narrative in order to build a legitimate collective sense of self. As for the sensemaking-oriented approach (Weick, 1995), it adopts a different perspective: the shared understandings of the members about what the organization is, result of cognitive processes carried out by members of the organization when they are questioning the central, enduring and distinctive features of their organization.
We draw from the second perspective. Through a case study conducted in 2010 within a large company facing critical change, we propose to empirically illustrate the meaning given by members of the organization to different constitutive dimensions of organizational identity. We focus especially on team managers, at the crossroads of all tensions in terms of identity and meaning at work.
This case study illustrates in particular the disorientation of team managers, torn between a dominant organizational identity exploded from the top of the organization, and a radically changing organizational context, which they are struggling to make sense and to give sense for their team. It results in identity profiles marked by hybridity and transition.
When such a situation is noticed, what managerial actions can be undertaken? Our aim in this article is to highlight the value of a polyphonic approach of change management (Pichault, 2009), and offer some thoughts on the development of a sensemaking articulated to the diversity of identities within the organization as well as the integration of this identity diversity concerns in the management practices. |
|
| Pages : |
45 - 76 |
|
| Type : |
Research paper |
|
| Keywords : |
change management, organizational identity, managers, sensemaking |
|
| APA : |
|
|
| Citations : |
9 |
|
| CAIRN : |
https://www.cairn.info/revue-internationale-de-psychosociologie-de-gestion-des-comportements-organisationnels-2012-46-page-45.htm |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Most cited papers |
| |
| Display TOP | 5 | 10 | 15 | 20 | |
| |
|
|
| Louis Jacques, Filion |
|
| Entrepreneurial representations: an emerging field of study |
|
| Volume XIV, Issue 32, 2008 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Cornelius, Castoriadis |
|
| The "rationality" of capitalism |
|
| Volume IV, Issue 08, 1997 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Robert, Paturel |
|
| Grandeurs and servitudes of entrepreneurship ... |
|
| Volume XIII, Issue 31, 2007 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Jean, Pralong |
|
| The image of work according to Y generation. An intergenerational comparison on 400 subjects using a cognitive mapping technique |
|
| Volume XVI, Issue 39, 2010 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Harry, Coenen |
|
| Action research. The relationship between researchers and the researched |
|
| Volume VII, Issue 16-17, 2001 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Pascale, Molinier |
|
| Subjective moral autonomy and the construction of sexual ldentity : the contribution of the psychodynamics of work |
|
| Volume III, Issue 05, 1996 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Jean-Louis, Le Grand |
|
| Defining life stories |
|
| Volume VI, Issue 14, 2000 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Pierre, Parlebas |
|
| A cultural break: from traditional games to sport |
|
| Volume IX, Issue 20, 2003 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Michel, Llory ; Annick, Llory |
|
| Management description and subjective description of work : differences ? An automobile assembly plant |
|
| Volume III, Issue 05, 1996 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Eugène, Enriquez |
|
| Psychosociology at the crossroads |
|
| Volume I, Issue 01, 1994 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| André, Sirota |
|
| lntermediate spaces of cultural experiences |
|
| Volume V, Issue 09, 1998 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Marie-Claire, Carpentier-Roy |
|
| New work organizations : paradoxes and suffering |
|
| Volume III, Issue 05, 1996 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| François, Pichault |
|
| Organizational intervention: a question of systemic legitimacy |
|
| Volume XII, Issue 26, 2006 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Sylvie, Grosjean ; Carole, Groleau |
|
| Organizational ethnography today |
|
| Volume XIX, Issue 48S, 2013 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Josée, Audet ; Paul, Couteret |
|
| Supporting entrepreneurs through coaching |
|
| Volume XII, Issue 27, 2006 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Mohamed, Bayad ; Sybille, Persson |
|
| Coaching at the service of managerial transformation |
|
| Volume XI, Issue 25, 2005 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Franck, Barès ; Sybille, Persson |
|
| Coaching as a stimulus to entrepreneurial potential ? |
|
| Volume XVII, Issue 42, 2011 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Marie-Josée, Bernard |
|
| Entrepreneurship as a process of resilience. Basics of a dialogue between two concepts |
|
| Volume XIV, Issue 32, 2008 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Anne, Marcellini ; Eric De, Leselec ; Jacques, Gleyse |
|
| Social integration through sport of people with disabilities |
|
| Volume IX, Issue 20, 2003 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| Catherine, Voynnet Fourboul |
|
| What Qualitative Data Analysis means |
|
| Volume XVIII, Issue 44, 2012 Afficher plus |
|
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
